Sustainable
The Great Dilemma
The website is an attempt to raise awareness of sustainability and highlight the urgency of taking action.
We are speechless and do not know how to overcome it in order to make reality comprehensible, to adequately describe the seriousness of the situation...
Read time: 7 min
The rapidly declining biodiversity is a serious risk to the food security of mankind...
Read time: 3 min
In the most severely affected countries, pollution-related disease is responsible for more than one death in four…
Read time: 2 min
We need very different answers to the environmental and climate challenges than the ones we have provided over the past 40 years...
Read time: 3 min
Digitalization is changing almost every aspect of our lives, while sustainability has not yet become a reality in most areas...
Read time: 3 min
It does not work without growth, there is no completely green growth, and normal growth inevitably leads to ecological disaster...
Read time: 4 min
The incentives in today's economic system are still one-sidedly promoting the exploitation of nature and man...
Read time: 3 min
The question is not how? The question is when do we decide to do business more sustainably?…
Read time: 4 min
Where do we stand?
© Alexander Sviridov | Shutterstock, Inc. [US] 2021
We are speechless and do not know how to overcome it in order to make reality comprehensible, to adequately describe the seriousness of the situation.
George Marshall. Don't Even Think About It - Why Our Brains Are Wired to Ignore Climate Change. 2014
An entire society is stuck between the feeling of impending catastrophe and the inability to admit this feeling.
Quote from Joanna Macy, Eco-philosopher, Activist and System Scientist.
What we are experiencing now with climate change has already catastrophic effects. But that is nothing compared to what awaits us if we simply carry on like this.
It's an experiment with an uncertain outcome. It can be compared to driving at top speed on the motorway in dense fog.
Translated from: Climate researcher Mojib Latif. In: Ulrike Hagen. «Alles Bisherige übertroffen»: Klimaforschende über aktuelle Entwicklungen beim Wetter. Frankfurter Rundschau. 03.11.2023
Concepts such as planetary boundaries, the Earth Overshoot Day and the material footprint show that the ecological crisis is much broader than climate change and that the energy transition alone will not be a sufficient response.
Translated from: Jens Beckert. 2024. Verkaufte Zukunft – Warum der Kampf gegen den Klimawandel zu scheitern droht.
When we have defeated nature, we will find ourselves on the losing side.
Translated quote from Konrad Lorenz, biologist and Nobel Prize winner.
The goals for a sustainable development are set [UN Agenda 2030 with 17 goals]. However, we currently do not know the conditions under which humanity can implement the measures to achieve these sustainability goals globally.
Christian Berg. Sustainable Action. Overcoming the Barriers. 2020.
Sustainability is on everyone's lips, in politics, business and in private life. Everyone has an idea of what the term means and sets different priorities. The term is therefore in danger of meaning «everything and nothing».
Translated from: Agentur für Forschung. 2019. Wahrnehmung von "Nachhaltigkeit" - Bericht zur qualitativen Studie. Mannheim, 05. September 2019
Greenwashing: A research project fundet by the European Union (2023) revealed that more than half of the environmental claims made regarding products and services - 53% to be exact - are either ambiguous, deceptive, or unfounded, with 40% of claims lacking evidence altogehter.
Alexandra Walker and Hélène Guadin. Paint it Green: Strategies for Detecting and Combatting Greenwashing in ESG Ratings. Sustainability Institute. 2024
Instead of sustainability - which is a pipe dream - we should try to achieve resilience.
One of the consequences of the pursuit of growth is the need for more efficiency. But if you do things to increase efficiency, you almost inevitably reduce resilience.
Translated from: Interview with Dennis Maedows, who became famous 50 years ago with «Limits to Growth». In:Urs Reichardt und Marlene Weiss. Der westliche Lebensstil wird nicht mehr lange fortbestehen. Leben und Gesellschaft. Heft 7/22. 2022.
© Ulrich Brunner 2023. Wallpaper © ittipon | Shutterstock, Inc. [US] 2018
The past decades have brought unprecedented prosperity to many people. However, our planet and a huge number of people are paying a high price for this.
This is the historic novelty of the current situation: As we run ever closer to the edge of the environmental envelope – the conditions within which our species can thrive – the development of the rich world systematically undercuts the conditions for survival of billions of people in the climate danger zone.
They are not so much exploited or bypassed as victimised by the climactic effects of economic growth taking place elsewhere. This violent and indirect entanglement is new in its quality and scale.
Adam Tooze. Global conferences such as the upcoming Cop28 may seem like staid and ritualistic affairs. But they matter. The Guardian 23.11.2023
The pressure of the global middle and upper classes on our planet's vital ecological systems has now become so strong that a climatic and ecological destabilization of the Earth has begun. This destabilization endangers the ecological foundations of life, which include a stable climate, a functioning biosphere, sufficient availability of clean water, healthy soil and clean air.
We need a discussion about sufficiency as a «Strategy of the Enough» - the hitherto neglected dimension of future policy.
Sufficiency as a «Strategy of the Enough».German Advisory Council on the Environment. 2024.
The question arises: What philosophy of life is behind the insatiability of us wealthy people who live so stubbornly and so dispassionately and morosely at the expense of others and the environment?
Translated from: Gabriela Simon: Mehr Genuss! Mehr Faulheit! Mehr Schlendrian! Die Zeit Nr. 42/1992
It is almost ironic that the reductions in CO2 emissions that have been achieved in a number of countries in recent decades can be attributed primarily to savings among the lower and middle social classes, while the CO2 emissions of the wealthy have continued to rise unaffected by the climate debate.
Translated from: Jens Beckert. 2024. Verkaufte Zukunft – Warum der Kampf gegen den Klimawandel zu scheitern droht.
Living off the fossil fuel deposits of the carboniferous era for more than two centuries gave us a false sense of an open-ended and unlimited future where everything was possible and with little price to pay. [...].
We called this era the «Age of Progress». Climate Change is now the bill come due.
Jeremy Rifkin, economist and journalist. The Green New Deal. Why the Fossil Fuel Civilisation Will Collapse by 2028, and the Bold Economic Plan to Save Life on Earth. 2019
© studiostoks | Shutterstock, Inc. [US] 2023
Our way of life and our economy are causing major environmental impacts and the climate change and are increasingly endangering our livelihood and living together on Earth.
Even in the Global Risk Report 2022 of the World Economic Forum WEF, five of the six biggest global risks are ecological and the sixth is weapons of mass destruction.
For example:
- Extreme weather events with great damage to property, infrastructure and human life.
- Governments and businesses fail to mitigate and adapt to climate change.
- Great loss of biodiversity and collapse of ecosystems with irreversible consequences for the environment, which leads to a severe depletion of resources for humanity and industry.
© Andrey_Kuzmin | Shutterstock, [US] 2023
No coming catastrophe has ever been studied as thoroughly as global warming. And none has ever been so thoroughly ignored.
The first World Climate Conference was held in Geneva back in 1979. World Climate Conferences have been held annually since 1995 and nonetheless global greenhouse gas emissions are still increasing every year.
At the 2021 climate summit in Glasgow, the states agreed to reduce greenhouse gas emissions by 45% by 2030, compared to 2010 levels. The aim was to limit global warming below 2°C.
However, studies on the effectiveness of the existing nationally determined contributions to reduce their emissions have now revealed: if they were implemented to this extent, global emissions in 2030 would not be lower, but around 9 % higher than in 2010.
According to United Nations – Climate Change. New Analysis of National Climate Plans: Insufficient Progress Made, COP28 Must Set Stage for Immediate Action. 14 November 2023.
For the young people who show up in the statistics as concerned or extremely concerned, the reports about the climate crisis are not nearly as depressing as the fact that these reports are ignored.
Translated from: Daniel Graf. Ja, Zukunftslust, verdammt! REPUBLIK 14.02.2023
© klublu | Shutterstock, [US] 2023
The inequality in wealth, resource use and CO2 emissions between countries and also within societies is enormous.
The inequality of the global labour division leads to an unbelievable hypocrisy in the climate debate, in which the countries of the global South are blamed for the overexploitation of their nature, although the benefits go to a large extent to the global North, which also enables the overexploitation in the first place with its technology and financial capital.
Translated from: Beckert Jens. 2024. Verkaufte Zukunft. Warum der Kampf gegen den Klimawandel zu scheitern droht.
The richest 1% of humanity is responsible for more carbon emissions than the poorest 66%, with dire consequences for vulnerable communities and global efforts to tackle the climate emergency.
A report shows that in 2019 Africa, which is home to about one in six of the world population, was responsible for just 4% of emissions.
According to Jonathan Watts. Richest 1% account for more carbon emissions than poorest 66%, report says. The Guardian, 20.11.2023. Data based on the report of Oxfam International. Climate Equality: A planet for the 99%.
It is understandable why emission-reduction policies that ignore these vast inequalities are unlikely to gain widespread support and may meet with strong opposition.
Richard Wilkinson and Kate Pickett. From inequality to sustainability. Earth4all. 2022.
It is completely comprehensible that a large part of the world's population finds economic growth, which after all means prosperity, more important than serious climate protection measures. The great task of civilisation is to solve this very conflict.
Translated from: Ernst Ulrich von Weizsäcker. So reicht das nicht! Was wir in der Klimakrise jetzt wirklich brauchen. 2022.
Without decisive action to drastically reduce socio-economic inequalities, there is no solution to the environmental and climate crisis.
Piketty Thomas. 2022. Brief history of equality.
© PX Media | Shutterstock, [US] 2023
People don't learn from clever books or arguments. They learn when their experiences no longer match their stories. When their knowledge about the world no longer applies. Then they are ready to think about alternatives.
Translated from: Bernhard Ott. Historiker Philipp Blom: Wie der Mensch wieder hoffen kann. Tages-Anzeiger 30.08.2024
Today's belief and thinking patterns all come from the time of a world almost empty of people and are not suitable for today's world full of people.
Today, actually since the mid of the twentieth century, humanity lives in a full world. A hundred years ago there were around 1,700, by 1950 around 2,500 and today around 8,000 million people live on our planet.
The limits are tangible, palpable in almost everything people do. And yet the world continues to pursue a policy of growth, as if we were still living in the empty world of that time, when the abundance of natural resources on Earth seemed endless.
According to Weizsäcker v. Ernst Ulrich and Anders Wijkman. 2017. Come on! - Capitalism, Short-Terminism, Population and the Destruction of the Planet.
As long as man was small in numbers and limited in technology, he could realistically regard the Earth as an infinite reservoir, an infinite source of inputs and an infinite cesspool for outputs. Today we can no longer make this assumption.
Earth as a Space ship, K.E. Boulding May 10 1965. Washington State University Committee on Space Sciences.
Our institutions and governance have been designed for a world characterised by relative stability and progress, but they have not been designed to steer our society in times of rapid change, when widely held assumptions, such as the pursuit for growth, are turning against us.
We need policymakers to take bold and ambitious action that embraces the urgency and interplay of overlapping crises while ensuring a truly just and inclusive transition.
Katy Wiese, the Senior Policy Officer at the EEB in: Andreas Budiman. The tricky path to financing our way out of the climate crisis. Meta from European Environmental Bureau EEB. April 5, 2023.
We are looking for a grand narrative that will overcome the present gloom. But we forget that many a grand narrative from the past has led to disaster.
For the moment, we have to accept that there is not yet a good answer to the great challenges of our time, perhaps there cannot even be one.
We do not know whether and how major disruptions caused by climate change can be avoided; for the time being, we can only experiment with small interim solutions.
Translated from: Jürgen Wiebicke. 2024. Erste Hilfe für Demokratie-Retter.
For now, the urgent need is to dismantle and stop the damage that is being done, not to fix and repair.
It is not yet the time to rebuild. Humanity needs to avert catastrophe before it thinks about groping its way to a better world.
Graeme Maxton. 2018. Change! Why we need a radical turnaround. Download pdf – book.
With regard to the fight against climate change, the dilemma is obvious.
On the one hand, consumption in an economy dominated by fossil fuels increases CO2 emissions and also causes other environmental damage, such as loss of biodiversity. The more we consume, the greater the impact on the environment.
On the other hand, the social system is based economically, politically and culturally precisely on this consumption and its further increase.
Translated from: Beckert Jens. 2024. Verkaufte Zukunft. Warum der Kampf gegen den Klimawandel zu scheitern droht.
Modern societies have more detailed knowledge than ever before about the state of and changes in the environment and about the causes, consequences, connections and interactions of these changes.
However, their political will and their political ability to stop and possibly reverse these changes has not grown as a result of this knowledge, but has perhaps even shrunk.
Translated from: Ingolfur Blühdorn. Die Gesellschaft der Nicht-Nachhaltigkeit. Skizze einer umweltsoziologischen Gegenwartsdiagnose. In: Nachhaltige Nicht-Nachhaltigkeit. 2020. Seiten 83-160
© Ulrich Brunner 2023
The way we live is a problem for our preservation as a society. […]. Adapting our way of life means that our actions have to align more and more with the side effects they unintentionally generate. […].
But it is not clear how this can be achieved. And because it's not clear, we have so many strange offerings on the market, from climate change denial to green capitalism.
Translated from: Pascal Blum. Zukunftsforscher Philipp Staab im Interview: Die Art und Weise, wie wir leben, ist ein Problem für unsere Erhaltung als Gesellschaft». Tages-Anzeiger. 22.04.2023
The sum of the scientific evidence is clear: climate change is a threat to human well-being and the health of the planet. Any further delay in concerted, forward-looking global action on adaptation and mitigation will miss a narrow and rapidly closing window of opportunity to secure a liveable and sustainable future for all.
IPCC Intergovernmental Panel On Climate Change. Climate Change 2022 – Impacts, Adaptation and Vulnerability.
However, people must not be told the fairy tale that the climate targets are compatible with the conventional growth approach.
Translated from: Günther Bachmann - Former Secretary-General of German Council for Sustainable Development. Interview 12.08.2021
Finally, the justified and serious question of a cabaret artist on the prevailing situation:
Do we really want to achieve the climate protection targets or are we content with climate targets?
Translated from: Christoph Sieber - Kabarettist. Ich will mich nicht gewöhnen. 3 Sat Festival 2021
Climate
Like when fever strikes, global warming is a symptom of a deeper malaise. Climate change is telling us loud and clear that our growth-based economy is unsustainable.
Margarita Mediavilla in: Khaled Diab. 2021. How Europe can grow without growing. European Environmental Bureau META.
Even today, we are presumably much better at understanding the social consequences of climate change than the social conditions for limiting it.
Christian Berg. 2020. Sustainable Action. Overcoming the Barriers.
The rights of future generations are just as weak in today's political decisions as the rights of people in the Global South or the rights of nature.
None of the signatory states to the Paris Climate Agreement have yet fulfilled their commitments. Externalising the costs of our lifestyle is still too easy for political actors to face up to the responsibility of restructuring and doing without.
Translated from: Josef Mackert. Newsletter WBGU Wissenschaftlicher Beirat der Bundesregierung Globale Umweltveränderungen. 22.10.2024
For more than 6,000 years, the human race has learned to live within a relatively narrow band of environmental and climatic fluctuations. The mean annual temperature over that period has been around 13ºC.
Currently, around 1% of the Earth's land surface - mainly in the hottest parts of the Sahara - has an average annual temperature of 29ºC.
By 2070, almost a fifth of the Earth's land surface could reach these temperatures, and this could affect around 30% of the forecasted world population.
Chi Xu etal. 2020. Future of the human climate niche. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS) Vol. 117 | No. 21.
2022 was the warmest year in Switzerland since measurements began in 1864.
Source: MeteoSchweiz 2023: Klimabulletin Jahr 2022. Zürich
Switzerland is already experiencing the clear effects of climate change. MeteoSwiss records show that Switzerland has been warming twice as much as the global average. The last decade [2014-2023] was 2.7 °C warmer compared to the pre-industrial era.
Translated from: Ana M. Vicedo-Cabrera. Der Klimawandel ist nicht nur ein Problem für künftige Generationen. Akademie der Naturwissenschaften Schweiz. ProClim Forum für Klima und globalen Wandel. Nr. 79 2024, S. 4-5
In 2024, 37.4 billion tonnes of CO₂ will be emitted from fossil fuels. This is an increase of 0.8% from the previous year.
Source: Global Carbon Project. November 2024
© Ulrich Brunner 2024. Wallpaper © Scott Book | Shutterstock, Inc. [US] 2019
Greenhouse gases - CO2, methane, nitrous oxide and fluorinated gases - reached a record 57.1bn tonnes of CO2equivalent in 2023. A continuation of current policies would result in a 100% chance of exceeding 1.5°C, a 97% chance of exceeding 2°C and a 37% chance of exceeding 3°C by 2100.
CarbonBrief. UNEP: New climate pledges need 'quantum leap' in ambition to deliver Paris goals. 24. 10.2024
The Global North's share of Global Warming to date is over 60 %, of China around 15 % and of all other countries together around 24 %.
Source: Global Carbon Project 2023
© Ulrich Brunner 2023. Wallpaper © Barnaby Chambers | Shutterstock, Inc. [US] 2019
Fossil fuels currently generate around 80% of the primary energy consumed worldwide.
Source: International Energy Agency's World Energy Outlook 2023.
© Ulrich Brunner 2023. Wallpaper © 24Novembers | Shutterstock, Inc. [US] 2023
In stark contrast to the trickle of climate finance, fossil fuel subsidies have surged in recent years. In 2022, total spending on subsidies for oil, natural gas and coal reached a record $7 trillion [according to IMF]. That's $2 trillion more than in 2020.
Chelsea Harvey and Zia Weise. The state of the planet in 10 numbers. Politico.eu. November 20, 2023
Since the year 2000, global consumption of fossil fuels has risen by 45%.
In a world with rising energy demand, more oil, gas and coal is being burnt, not less, regardless of the massive expansion of renewable energies - despite all the climate warnings.
Translated from: Beckert Jens. 2024. Verkaufte Zukunft. Warum der Kampf gegen den Klimawandel zu scheitern droht.
Resilient ecosystems
© Frank Wortmann + © arpitcoolboy + © Sandra-Dombrovsky + © Aleks14 | Shutterstock, Inc. [US] 2019/2023
There is no prospect of achieving climate targets without protecting ecosystems at the same time. Reducing greenhouse gas emissions alone is not sufficient.
It is an illusion to believe that we can continue to live as before if we only fight CO₂.
No car, road or aeroplane is sustainable. And yet it is said everywhere that driving and flying could suddenly be sustainable. The myth of climate neutrality is particularly misleading. The term means that either no greenhouse gases are caused or that they can all be offset.
Politicians and scientists are passionately involved in this game of CO2 quantification. Once CO2 has been combated, so the supposed logic goes, humans can continue to live just as before. However, this self-reassurance only works as long as the focus is solely on CO2 and all other environmental damage is ignored.
Translated from: Albert Denk. Klimawandel: Es ist eine Illusion zu glauben, wir könnten weiterleben wie bisher, wenn wir nur das CO₂ bekämpfen. Süddeutsche Zeitung 2. August 2024
Major efforts are now needed to protect the natural carbon reservoirs such as forests, soils, peatlands and oceans, in order to simultaneously mitigate the rapidly advancing loss of biodiversity.
Some 50 percent of man-made greenhouse gas emissions are absorbed by natural ecosystems on land and in the sea.
Soils are, after the oceans, the second largest natural carbon sink. Peatlands cover only 3% of the land surface but absorb twice as much carbon as all the world's forests combined.
But since the pre-industrial era, it is estimated that more than 80 % of the world's wetlands have been lost due to changes in land use and drainage, and most of the remaining wetlands have been degraded.
WBGU. German Advisory Council on Global Change. Water in heated world. Summary. 2024
© Marti Bug Catcher | Shutterstock, Inc. [US] 2021
Climate change is also taking place above all in the oceans.
In 2022, the world's oceans, as given by ocean heat content, were again the hottest in the historical record and exceeded the previous 2021 record maximum.
Cheng, L., Abraham, J., Trenberth, K.E. et al. Another Year of Record Heat for the Oceans. Adv. Atmos. Sci. (2023).
The oceans cover more than 70 per cent of the surface of the planet. They are becoming warmer and sea levels are rising. To date, the oceans have absorbed about a quarter of global CO2 emissions. However, the oceans are becoming increasingly acidic as carbonic acid is formed during the absorption of CO2.
The lack of appropriate wastewater treatment and the release of pollutants from the manufacturing industry, agriculture, tourism, fisheries and shipping continue to put pressure on the ocean, with a negative impact on food security, food safety and marine biodiversity.
The ocean plays a crucial role in the achievement of the Sustainable Development Goals and the livelihoods of billions of people. We urgently need to change how we interact with it.
The Second World Ocean Assessment. United Nations. 2021.
The Climate Decade
Image generated by Shutterstock AI-Generator 2024
We think of climate change as slow, but it is unnervingly fast. We think of the technological change necessary to avert it as fast-arriving, but unfortunately it is deceptively slow, especially judged by just how soon we need it.
David Wallace-Wells. The Uninhabitable Earth. Life after Warming. 2019
The goal of halving global emissions by 2030 represents the absolute minimum we must achieve if we are to have at least a 50 per cent chance of safeguarding humanity from the worst impacts.
Christiana Figueres and Tom Rivett-Carnac. 2020. The Future We Choose - Surviving the Climate Crisis.
We are entering the «climate decade». A ten year period where our collective actions will determine the kind of world our children and grandchildren will inherit.
The Climate Decade. Ten Years to Deliver the Paris Agreement. The GlobeScan-SustainAbility Servey. 2019
© Alexander Mak | Shutterstock, Inc. [US] 2021
The primary challenge is to stop the flow of money to oil, coal and gas and to establish a clear path towards de-carbonization.
The «sustainability» of finance can be gauged by how far and how fast it shifts us away from the fossil fuel economy, rather than simply allowing the financial sector to develop new «green» markets alongside a core business that continues to bankroll climate change.
Oscar Reyes. Change Finance - Not the Climate. 2020
The climate crisis is not interested in the promise to be climate-neutral in 2050: It doesn't matter when humanity stops burning coal, oil and gas, and thus blowing greenhouse gases like CO2 into the atmosphere. It depends on how much we burn in the meantime.
If we do not make massive reductions by 2030 - that is, in less than 10 years - global warming will certainly exceed 2 degrees.
Translated from: Maria Stich. 18 Fakten über die Klimakrise, die jede:r wissen sollte. Perspective Daily. 27. März 2023
Biodiversity
© Ulrich Brunner 2024. Wallpaper © Pavel K, © Fostici and © oticki | Shutterstock, Inc. [US] 2020/23
The rapidly declining biodiversity on land and in the sea is a serious risk to the food security of mankind.
In 2022, 2.4 billion people, comprising relatively more women and people living in rural areas, did not have access to nutritious, safe and sufficient food all year round.
The State of Food Security and Nutrition in the World 2023 - in brief. FAO, IFAD, UNICEF, WFP and WHO.
While fossil records show that extinctions happen naturally, current extinction rates are estimated to be 100 to 1000 times higher today than what is considered natural.
Elizabeth Claire Alberts. Global biodiversity is in crisis, but how bad is it? It's complicated. Mongabay Series. 11. April 2022
© Ulrich Brunner 2024
Biodiversity means «biological variety» or «variety of life». Biodiversity can be described on three levels: the diversity of genes, the diversity of species and the diversity of habitats. These three levels of biodiversity are closely and dynamically interlinked.
Biodiversity is not only in itself worth preserving, but also provides indispensable services for society and the economy, so-called ecosystem services. The diversity of these services is immense: Among other things, biodiversity provides food, influences the climate, maintains water and air quality, is a component of soil formation and, last but not least, offers people space for recreation.
Translated from: Beate Kittl. 2024. Fragen und Antworten zur Biodiversität in der Schweiz. WSL Eidgenössische Forschungsanstalt für Wald, Schnee und Landschaft
In 2022, 188 countries
agreed at the 15th UN Biodiversity Conference with a ground-breaking final
declaration to protect at least 30 per cent of the world's land, sea and inland
waters by 2030.
© salcovern | Shutterstock, Inc. [US] 2023
Despite all our accomplishments, we owe our existence to a six-inch layer of topsoil and the fact that it rains.
Quote from Paul Harvey
Land use change linked to massive expansion of globalized, highly commercialized industrial agriculture is the main overarching driver of declining agrobiodiversity.
Globally, the FAO [Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations] estimates that 75 % of crop diversity was lost in the 20th century. Historically about 7,000 plant species were cultivated for food, today only about 80 plant species make major contributions to food supplies at the global level.
In fact, half of all plant-based calories come from only three species - rice, maize, and wheat. And 93 % of global meat supplies come from just four animal species - pigs, poultry, cattle, and buffalo.
Looking ahead, restoring agrobiodiversity - the richness of what we cultivate, breed, consume, and conserve in the wild - is crucial to ensure resilient food systems against the backdrop of climate change.
Swiss academies factsheets Vol.15 No.1. 2020. Variety is the source of life: Agrobiodiversity benefits, challenges, and needs.
The production of meat and dairy products already takes up 70 - 80 per cent of global agricultural land*), although it only covers 18 per cent of humanity's calorie requirements and 37 per cent of its protein needs.
Poore et al., Reducing food's environmental impacts through producers and consumers. Science 360, 987-992 (2018)
*) Cultivation of animal feed and grazing land for animals
Biodiversity is experiencing a dramatic, human-induced mass extinction worldwide [...]. This also greatly reduces the capacity of ecosystems to contribute to climate regulation and food security.
Only if there is a fundamental change in the way we manage land can we reach the targets of climate-change mitigation, avert the dramatic loss of biodiversity and make the global food system sustainable.
WBGU German Advisory Council on Global Change. 2020. Rethinking Land in the Anthropocene: from Separation to Integration.
© Kichigin | Shutterstock, Inc. [US] 2023
The oceans are home to an estimated one million animal and plant species. The phytoplankton in the oceans produce as much oxygen as all land plants combined.
Translated from: Greenpeace Schweiz. 2023. Wer atmet braucht das Meer.
Driven by climate change, marine biodiversity is undergoing a phase of rapid change that has proven to be even faster than changes observed in terrestrial ecosystems.
Hodapp D. etal. 2023. Climate change disrupts core habitats of marine species. Global Change Biology, 00, 1–14.
In seeking to curb climate change and biodiversity loss, the following steps are important:
Transformative change to a sustainable economic system. The economic development of countries and companies must also be measured by their management of natural resources.
No subsidies harmful to the climate and biodiversity. Countries around the world spend much more on environmentally harmful subsidies than on measures to protect the climate and biodiversity.
Radical reduction of greenhouse gas emissions. Only rapid decarbonisation can curb climate change. Agricultural GHG emissions from land-use change are also to be minimised.
Overcoming land-use conflicts. The use of land for buildings, transport, food production, climate protection and biodiversity conservation needs to be coordinated.
Environmental regulations for the financial sector. The financial sector has a major influence on economic activities which are harmful to biodiversity and the climate.
Reduced consumption of meat and dairy products. Natural ecosystems must no longer be converted to plantations, arable land or livestock farms. The agricultural, forestry and fishing sectors must sustainably manage those areas already in use. This also requires changes in dietary habits.
More funding for conservation. To achieve conservation goals, countries around the world need to invest many times the amount that is currently expended.
Ismail SA, Geschke J, Kohli M et al. (2021) Tackling climate change and biodiversity loss jointly. Swiss Academies Factsheet 16 (3)
Pollution
© Lightspring | Shutterstock, Inc. [US] 2024
Along with climate change and biodiversity loss, the pollution of air, water and soil is one of the major environmental crises of our time.
When ecological boundaries are exceeded, this also has significant health impacts. Despite recent heat waves, droughts, heavy rainfall events and the COVID-19 pandemic, policymakers and society still do not take this connection seriously enough.
The multiple environmental crises […] require profound change. Policymakers and society need to rethink approaches to these issues and recognise how strongly human health and the environment are interconnected.
SRU German Advisory Council on the Environment. For a Systematic Integration of Environment and Health. Summary 2023
Ambient air pollution, chemical pollution, and soil pollution - the forms of pollution produced by industry, mining, electricity generation, mechanised agriculture, and petroleum-powered vehicles - are all on the rise.
In the most severely affected countries, pollution-related disease is responsible for more than one death in four.
Like climate change, biodiversity loss, ocean acidification, desertification, and depletion of the world's fresh water supply, pollution endangers the stability of the Earth's support systems and threatens the continuing survival of human societies.
Pollution is now a substantial problem that endangers the health of billions, degrades the Earth's ecosystems, undermines the economic security of nations, and is responsible for an enormous global burden of disease, disability, and premature death.
Philip J. Landrigan etal. The Lancet Commission on pollution and health. www.thelancet.com Vol. 391 February 3, 2018
Water quality will continue to decline in the future if the discharge of inadequately treated wastewater – currently about 80 % of the world's wastewater – and with it pathogens, persistent chemicals, nutrients and solid waste continues.
WBGU. German Advisory Council on Global Change. Water in heated world. Summary. 2024
According to a new study, it is estimated that over four billion people worldwide do not have an adequate supply of drinking water. That is more than half of the world's population.
Esther E. Greenwood etal. Mapping safe drinking water use in low- and middle-income countries. Science 15. Aug 2024. Vol 385, Issue 6710 pp. 784 - 790
© Rroselavy | Shutterstock, Inc. [US] 2024
Because the increasing environmental and health problems often have common roots, synergies can be found in approaches to solving them. We are at a crossroads.
Planetary Health: What we need to talk about. German Advisory Council on Global Change (WBGU). 2021.
Climate change, biodiversity loss and global pollution must be halted in order to maintain the health of people and the planet.
Important, hitherto neglected starting points include stopping the exploration of fossil energy sources and strengthening the biosphere on land, in freshwater and in the sea - also to prevent zoonotic pandemics.
Health and environmental risks from emissions and the dumping of persistent wastes and chemicals in the air, soil and water should be prevented with a controlled circular economy and emissions regulations.
German Advisory Council on Global Change WBGU. Factsheet No. 8, 2023. Healthy Living.
Environmental Policy
The great fallacy of the environmental debate over the past 30 years has been the hope that an ecological turnaround can essentially be implemented with some technological innovation programme within the existing economic order.
However, the continuing impressive growth in prosperity has not been able to slow down climate pollution, resource consumption or the loss of biodiversity - on the contrary, all these pressures have increased massively.
Translated from: Uwe Schneidewind. Die Grosse Transformation - Eine Einführung in die Kunst gesellschaftlichen Wandels. 2018
That the transition to sustainability can be achieved through innovation and technology alone is a hypothesis for which there is insufficient evidence - on the contrary, there are many arguments against it.
Sufficiency as a «Strategy of the Enough».German Advisory Council on the Environment. 2024.
Technological innovation is absolutely important [...]. It is vital, in fact. We're going to need all the innovations and efficiency improvements we can get to drastically reduce the resource and carbon intensity of our economy.
But the problem we face doesn't have to do with technology. The problem has to do with growth. Over and over again, we see that the growth imperative wipes out all the gains our best technology delivers.
Jason Hickel. Less is more. How degrowth will save the world. 2020
© Ulrich Brunner 2024. Wallpapers © Lightspring + © Piyaset | Shutterstock, Inc. [US] 2019/23
Today, Europe continues to consume more resources and contribute more to environmental degradation than many other world regions. We do not only have to do more; we also have to do things differently.
We now need completely different answers to environmental and climate issues than those of the past 40 years.
The European Environment - State and Outlook 2020. European Environment Agency. 2019
Because problems can never be solved with the same way of thinking that created them.
Quote from Albert Einstein. 1946 - in light of the new threat of atomic weapons.
The longer one tries to apply the solution strategies that fit yesterday's problems to today's problems, the bigger they become, the problems.
Translated from: Harald Welzer. 2023. Zeiten Ende – Politik ohne Leitbild, Gesellschaft in Gefahr.
© ChristianChan | Shutterstock, Inc. [US] 2021
It is quite simply a fact that the current ways of life and economic activity have a comprehensive and deep impact on various ecosystems. Future generations [...] therefore face drastic and irreversible disadvantages.
To date, climate, environmental and sustainability policy has far from succeeded in achieving a sufficiently strong reduction in ecological burdens.
Translated from: Institut für ökologische Wirtschaftsforschung (IÖW): Gesellschaftliches Wohlergehen innerhalb planetaren Grenzen, Texte 89/2018
The climate crisis is actually a climate policy crisis, as we are sliding - insignificantly slowed down - towards a climate catastrophe as a result of inadequate action.
Translated from: Prof. Andreas Fischlin. Farewell lecture from 2 December 2024. Swiss Federal Institute of Technology Zurich.
© JrCasas | Shutterstock, Inc. [US] 2019
The experience of recent decades shows that political intervention in the market has never been sufficient or even aimed at stopping climate change.
This is why we speak of the climate crisis as the biggest government failure of all time, which has been quietly taking place despite all the requirements of environmental law.
Translated from: Beckert Jens. 2024. Verkaufte Zukunft. Warum der Kampf gegen den Klimawandel zu scheitern droht.
We need a policy shift that does not treat sustainability as a possible by-product of an economic growth agenda, but aims directly at sustainable consumption, production and investment.
Translated from: Maja Göpel. Unsere Welt neu denken - Eine Einladung 2020
Digitalization
© Geza Farkas | Shutterstock, Inc. [US] 2018
Digitalization and sustainability are often referred to as two megatrends that are shaping the economy and society. However, the two phenomena are very different:
Digitalization is massively changing reality and influencing almost every aspect of our lives, while sustainability is a normative goal that has not yet become a reality in most areas.
Maike Gossen and Otmar Lell. Sustainable consumption in the digital age. A plea for a systemic policy approach to turn risks into opportunities. GAIA 32/S1 (2023): 71 – 76
The combination of digital progress and capitalist ideology in a fully monetarised society obviously leads to a concentration of power among a few, mostly private, actors.
However, digitalization has contributed as much as nothing to solving the really big problems, such as distributive justice, hunger, educational injustice, wars, ethnic and religious conflicts, corruption. Because normally only ideas that can be made into money come onto the market.
Translated from: Jonas Lüscher, Writer - Interview in the newspaper Tages-Anzeiger, 06.01.2018
We will end up with «digital by default» unless we choose «digital by design».
We shouldn't view technology through the lenses of Big Tech where the role of algorithms is to replace humans [..].
We should start by valuing the outcomes that we want technology to help achieve such as reducing carbon and improving the returns to labour.
Mark Carney. Value(s) - Building a Better World for All. 2021
© Moor Studio | Shutterstock, Inc. [US] 2023
Overall, digitalization processes today tend to act as «fire accelerants», exacerbating existing non-sustainable trends such as the overuse of natural resources and growing social inequality in many countries.
On the one hand, it must be plainly stated that the digitalization of business and everyday life has so far been marginally oriented towards sustainability aspects.
On the other hand, digitalization offers an enormous range of possibilities for supporting the Great Transformation towards sustainability.
WBGU German Advisory Council on Global Change. Towards our Common Digital Future. 2019.
The three main objectives of ecological sustainability are decarbonisation, dematerialisation and renaturalisation. In theory at least, the growth of digital services can be compatible with the goals of ecological sustainability. But today's reality is far-removed from that ideal.
The consumption of energy and material is actually increasing as digitalisation expands. This situation will not change unless the majority of affected companies adopt the three ecological objectives as binding principles.
Ortwin Renn, et al. The opportunities and risks of digitalisation for sustainable development: a systemic perspective. GAIA 30/1(2021): 23-28
© Gorodenkoff | Shutterstock, Inc. [US] 2023
The energy consumption of digital infrastructure is increasing, because the intensity of use is growing faster than efficiency. It is true that microchips have become more energy-efficient by a factor of at least one billion over the last five decades.
This means that you can now calculate a billion times more for a kilowatt hour of electricity than fifty years ago. There is no other technical field in which energy efficiency is increasing so rapidly. But utilisation is growing even faster, which is why overall consumption is increasing sharply.
Translated from: Mathias Plüss. Interview mit Prof. Lorenz Hilty. Fussabdruck der Digitalisierung. Newsletter Planet Plüss. Tages-Anzeiger. 02.06.2024
The relation between digitalization and environmental sustainability is ambiguous. On the whole, the form of digitalization we have witnessed in the past decades has not solved any of the pressing environmental issues of our time: Despite innovative small-scale initiatives, it can be noted that in none of the key sectors – transport, energy, agriculture, housing, consumer goods – did the introduction of digital tools so far spur transformation towards sustainable alternatives.
T. Santarius etal. Digitalization and Sustainability: A Call for a Digital Green Deal. Environmental Science and Policy 147 (2023) 11–14
© Alexander Limbach | Shutterstock, [US] 2024
The enormous design opportunities of digitalisation as a formative force of the 21st century must be placed at the service of sustainable development as the most pressing design task of the 21st century.
Translated from: Wuppertal Institut (2021): Digitalisierung gestalten - Transformation zur Nachhaltigkeit ermöglichen: Studie im Rahmen des Projekts «Shaping the Digital Transformation».
Growth
© M-SUR | Shutterstock, [US] 2018
We have to face the growth dilemma that is:
Giving up on growing our current economy means the risk of economic and social collapse.
Maintaining the conventional growth means the risk of destroying global ecosystems that are our basis of existence.
Tim Jackson. Prosperity without Growth - Foundations for the economy of tomorrow. 2016
Three per cent growth means doubling the size of the global economy every twenty-three years [...]. This might be OK if GDP were just plucked out of thin air. But it's not. It is coupled to energy and resource use [...].
Jason Hickel. 2020. Less is More. How degrowth will save the world.
It's a dilemma: it does not work without growth, there is no completely green growth, and normal growth inevitably leads to ecological disaster.
Translated from: Ulrike Herrmann. Goodbye, Kapitalismus: So kann der Übergang zu einer neuen Wirtschaftsordnung gelingen. Perspective Daily 11. Januar 2021
© Ulrich Brunner 2024. Wallpaper © smatch | Shutterstock, Inc. [US] 2018
Continued growth isn't a fairy tale, it's a necessity. But not just any growth.
The power of the market needs to be directed to achieving what society wants. That requires measures of income and welfare that reflect our values.
We need a world where we are no longer guided solely by measures like GDP*).
Mark Carney. Value(s) - Building a Better World for All. 2021.
*) GDP stands for Gross Domestic Product and represents the total monetary value of all final goods and services produced and sold within a country during a period of time.
© Ueli Hafner 2022
We urgently need a clear vision, a bold policy, and a truly robust strategy to find the way out of the growth dilemma.
The growth dilemma is barely taken into account by the normal policy-makers and is mentioned only marginally in public debate.
Tim Jackson. Prosperity without Growth - Foundations for the economy of tomorrow. 2016
It is clear that there are no simple answers to this - none that could be proposed without proposing at the same time a transformation in the whole of the way we think, work and order our lives.
David Fleming, Surviving the Future: Culture, Carnival and Capital in the Aftermath of the Market Economy. 2016
© Ulrich Brunner 2024. Wallpaper © Anderl | Shutterstock, Inc. [US] 2018
The conventional reaction to the growth dilemma is the call for decoupling of economic growth from resource consumption, including harmful environmental impacts.
The decoupling is to be achieved with more efficient production processes. However, producing more efficiently means an increase in productivity and this enables further growth with additional resource consumption.
In the capitalist economy, all efficiency gains are in principle transferred to new economic activities. This reinvestment of efficiency gains is precisely the economic principle on the basis of which growth and profits are achieved.
Translated from Beckert Jens. 2024. Verkaufte Zukunft. Warum der Kampf gegen den Klimawandel zu scheitern droht.
So far, global environment and climate policies have at best achieved relative decoupling*) between GDP and resource use respectively Greenhouse gas emissions.
Helmut Haberl et al 2020. A systematic review of the evidence on decoupling of GDP, resource use and GHG emissions, part II: synthesizing the insights. Environ. Res. Lett. 15 065003
*) A relative decoupling of resource consumption and economic growth means that although resource consumption increases less strongly in a more sustainable but still growing economy, it still increases.
In the case of an absolute decoupling, resource consumption would no longer increase despite a growing economy.
We therefore cannot rely solely on efficiency measures and technological innovations.
Because we have so far not succeeded in decoupling global economic growth from resource consumption and greenhouse gas emissions in absolute terms.
© Ulrich Brunner 2024
The gap between efficient production and efficient collection and recycling of materials is gigantic.
The global use of materials is accelerating. It has more than tripled since 1970. Despite efforts to move towards a circular economy, the proportion of recycled materials in the total consumption of all materials has decreased in recent years.
The share of secondary materials*) consumed by the global economy has decreased from 9.1% in 2018 to 7.2% in 2023, a 21% drop over the course of five years.
The Circularity Gap Report 2024 - Executive summary. Circal Economy Foundation.*) Secondary materials originate from collected, disposed materials and differ from primary materials extracted from nature.
Resource extraction and processing are responsible for 90% of global biodiversity loss, 50% of global greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, and over 30% of air-pollution-related health impacts.
Piotr Barczak. How a circular economy can cure globale resource overconsumption. Meta from European Environmental Bureau. July 16, 2024.
© Ulrich Brunner 2024. Wallpaper © Anderl | Shutterstock, Inc. [US] 2018
Not only is there no empirical evidence supporting the existence of a decoupling of economic growth from environmental pressures on anywhere near the scale needed to deal with environmental breakdown, but also, and perhaps more importantly, such decoupling appears unlikely to happen in the future.
Parrique T. etal. 2019. European Environmental Bureau. Decoupling debunked: Evidence and arguments against green growth as a sole strategy for sustainability.
Therefore, two different decoupling tasks must be pursued:
(1) decoupling the production of goods and services from unsustainable natural consumption and
(2) decoupling the satisfaction of human needs from the imperative to ever more consumption.
Maja Göpel. The Great Mindshift. 2016
There will be no one simple solution for decoupling prosperity and the destruction of nature, but if we don't manage it, we will have to adapt to the new conditions. And they'll be tough.
Translated from: Interview with Harald Lesch. Digitale Welten riechen nicht. GeoPlus 29.09. 2021
We have
the almost impossible task of satisfying the basic needs of what will soon be 9
to 10 billion people while at the same time respecting the Earth's
ecological limits.
In this context, it is important to remember the great inequality. To illustrate this, three examples:
Around 20 percent of the world's population, mainly people in rich countries but also wealthy people worldwide, account for around 80 percent of total global resource consumption.
Multiple sources: Order of magnitude, no exact data are available.
80 percent of the world's population has never boarded an aircraft and only 1 per cent of the world's population is responsible for half of all flight emissions.Stefan Gössling, Andreas Humpe. 2020. The global scale, distribution and growth of aviation: Implication for climate change.
The richest 10 per cent produce almost half of the world's climate-damaging emissions. A third of these 10 per cent live in emerging countries.
Translated from: Interview with Irmi Seidl. Radio SRF 2 Kultur, Kultur-Aktualität. 9.9.2022
Economy
© underworld | Shutterstock, Inc. [US] 2019
The incentives in today's economic system are still one-sidedly promoting the exploitation of nature and man.
A realistic assumption is that only very far-reaching changes in the economy, and even in human civilisation, can enforce a reasonably tolerable future for our planet.
Translated from: Ernst Ulrich von Weizsäcker. 2022. So reicht das nicht! Was wir in der Klimakrise jetzt wirklich brauchen.
It is an epochal contradiction that the idea of sustainability and the hectic quarterly thinking emerged almost simultaneously in corporations: The conviction that politics and business should be laid out very long-term, and the compulsion to report higher profits from quarter to quarter.
Translated from: Roger de Weck. 2009. Nach der Krise - Gibt es einen andern Kapitalismus?
© Prazis Images| Shutterstock, Inc. [US] 2023
The world's leaders are correctly fixated on economic growth as the answer to virtually all problems, but they're pushing with all their might in the wrong direction.
Hence, we end up with global economic policy that was crafted to alleviate poverty but many decades later has morphed into a poverty trap, economically enslaving whole nations, destabilizing democracies, and «crowdfunding» environmental catastrophe.
We have watched the purpose of our economy morph from valuing our future to discounting it entirely.
Dixson-Declève S. et.al. 2022. Earth for All. A Survival Guide for Humanity. A Report to the Club of Rome.
To detach Nature from economic reasoning is to imply that we consider ourselves to be external to Nature.
We may have increasingly queried the absence of Nature from official conceptions of economic possibilities, but the worry has been left for Sundays. On week-days, our thinking has remained as usual.
The fault is not in economics; it lies in the way we have chosen to practise it.
Partha Dasgupta. The Economics of Biodiversity: The Dasgupta Review. Abridged Version. 2021
In a planetary emergency where scientific evidence plays a secondary role to the power of private capital in the formation of policies that will determine the future of life on Earth, it's downright dangerous.
Charlie J. Gardner. Post on LinkedIn. 07.10.2024
The current economic organisation, which is based on uncontrolled capital movements without social and ecological targets, is often enough tantamount to a kind of neo-colonialism in favour of the richest. Politically and ecologically, the development is untenable.
Piketty Thomas. 2022. Brief history of equality.
© mipan | Shutterstock, Inc. [US] 2020
The malaise in corners of finance can be remedied only by a combination of regulatory measures and true cultural change.
Market standards were poorly understood, often ignored and always lacked teeth. Too many participants neither felt responsible for the system nor recognised the full impact of their actions.
Bad behavior went unchecked, proliferated and eventually became the norm.
Mark Carney. Value(s) - Building a Better World for All. 2021
Leading economists are proposing an economic turnaround:
Politicians should say goodbye to neoliberalism and take more care of the people. Decades of poorly managed globalisation, over-reliance on market self-regulation and austerity have eroded governments' ability to respond effectively to the current crises.
To avert greater damage to humanity and the planet, we urgently need to address the causes of people's discontent.
Translated from: Forum New Economy. Appell international führender Ökonomen für eine Agenda gegen Populismus. Pressemitteilung vom 29. Mai 2024
Liberal democracies are today confronted with a wave of popular distrust in their ability to serve the majority of their citizens and solve the multiple crises that threaten our future.
We are living through a critical period. Markets on their own will neither stop climate change nor lead to a less unequal distribution of wealth. Trickle-down has failed.
What is needed is a new political consensus addressing the deep drivers of people's distrust instead of merely focusing on the symptoms, or falling into the trap of populists who pretend to have simple answers.
The Berlin Summit Declaration - Winning back the people. Forum New Economy. May 2024
© Janossy Gergely and Saigh Anees | Shutterstock, Inc. [US] 2023
Economic growth based on exploitation - the business model of the rich West for 400 years - has reached its limits. The exploitability of people and the ecosystems [...] leads to migration in millions and catastrophic environmental impacts.
Translated from: Philipp Blom. Was auf dem Spiel steht. 2017
It is the conditions of any future economy that need to be redeveloped: For all the great achievements that we can look back on have only been at the price of not taking into account either the natural conditions or the living situations of people in other parts of the world.
Translated from: Harald Welzer. Alles könnte anders sein - Eine Gesellschaftsutopie für freie Menschen. 2019
The ecological problems will increase and so will the social and economic upheavals. [...]
We need to ask ourselves what kind of economic system will serve the people and also maintain the ecological foundations. Today's does not.
Translated from: Interview with the economist Irmi Seidl. Der ökologische Umbau wird die Arbeitswelt verändern. Tages-Anzeiger. 15.02.2020
Sustainability
© Gustavo Frazao | Shutterstock, Inc. [US] 2019
The question is not how? The question is when do we decide to do business more sustainably?
The world is changing – environmentally, socially, economically. The only uncertainties are the pace and direction of that change, and whether societies will find pathways to long-term sustainability and prosperity or instead settle for increasing volatility and accelerating decline.
Transitions are very rarely smooth, and the sustainability transformation is perhaps the most difficult that global societies have faced. Seemingly contradictory truths and deep uncertainties must be factored into short-, medium-, and long-term plans.
Like previous transitions – the ongoing digital transformation is a good example – significant value is at risk, and enormous value can be created.
Jacco Kroon etal. 2024. Report: Catching the wave - Seizing the opportunities of sustainability transformation. Executive Summary. ERM Sustainability Institute and World Business Council for Sustainable Development.
We are not on a sustainable path. Within the lifetime of one single generation the world population, global CO2 emissions, resource and energy consumption increased at an unprecedented rate.
© Ulrich Brunner 2024.
Source: Christian Berg. 2020. Online presentation of the new report to the Club of Rome – Sustainable Action. Overcoming the Barriers.
Sustainable development is hardly conceivable without
- moving away from the predominantly linear economy towards a consistent circular economy,
- simultaneously cutting back on over-consumption,
- rapidly reducing CO2 emissions and
- a fundamental change in the way we manage land.
We must move from the deeply internalized attitude of competition and self-interest to a basic attitude of cooperation and common good, if for example, we really want to curb global climate change.
Definition of Sustainability
Sustainability is a development that satisfies the needs of the present without risking that future generations will not be able to meet their own needs.
Brundtland Report - Our Common Future. World Commission on the Environment and Development, 1987
Sustainability [ecology] is a principle according to which no more can be consumed, than can respectively be regrown, regenerated, and provided again in the future.
Translated from: Duden German Dictionary
Sustainability means - concisely formulated - good life for about ten billion people within the ecological boundaries on our planet.
Translated from: Uwe Schneidewind. Die Grosse Transformation - Eine Einführung in die Kunst gesellschaftlichen Wandels. 2018
Sustainability is a guiding concept to secure and foster humane living conditions for all people worldwide, in the present and future, and to facilitate restoring and preserving the environmental foundations to enable this.
Mark Lawrence. 2023. How can I live sustainably. RIFS Research Institute for Sustainability Potsdam.
As simple as these definitions are, it is difficult to achieve a unified, shared understanding of sustainability.
But without a common understanding of sustainability, the transformation to a more sustainable society can hardly be accomplished.
Transformation means that we determine what we want to keep and preserve - and at the same time what we want to part from.
Translated from: Stefan Brunnhuber. 2023. Die Kunst der Transformation – Wie wir uns anpassen und die Welt verändern.
17 Sustainable Development Goals
UN Agenda 2030
The Sustainable Development Goals intend to guide world politics towards a sustainable development. This means that all states are called upon to solve the world's pressing challenges together.
The 2030 Agenda is not an instruction manual on how to achieve the 17 Sustainable Development Goals. Rather, it is a compass.
People should have relevant information and awareness of sustainable development by 2030 - all across the world.
In order to achieve the UN 2030 Agenda's Goals, we need to fundamentally change the way we do business and consume.
Although digitalization is hardly mentioned in the 2030 Agenda, it will greatly influence its implementation.
WBGU German Advisory Counsil on Global Change. Digitalization: What we need to talk about. 2018
The SDG Progress Report [2023 = Half-time Agenda 2030] shows that just 12 percent of the Sustainable Development Goal targets are on track. Progress on 50 percent is weak and insufficient. Worst of all, we have stalled or gone into reverse on more than 30 percent of the SDGs.
António Guterres. Secretary-General's remarks to launch the Special Edition of the Sustainable Development Goals Progress Report. 25 April 2023
The UN warned that without better performance by the G20 countries, which are responsible for 75 percent of global CO2 emissions, the UN Agenda 2030 for Sustainable Development will fail.
Above all, the consumption behaviour of the rich industrialised countries is the subject of criticism.
If, as forecasted, the world's population increases to 9.7 billion by 2050, humans and the planet will face many challenges. Asia's rise will undoubtedly also lead to a higher energy demand, more consumption and production.
This calls for a public discussion on a broad approach to sustainability. It is not a backward-looking «eco-agenda» but overdue reforms for economic modernization, climate protection and innovation.
Translated from: Sabina Wölkner. Agenda 2030: Mut zur Nachhaltigkeit! Konrad Adenauerstiftung. 2019
Our dilemma as
environmentally-aware affluent citizens
© Aleutie | Shutterstock, Inc. [US] 2018
If we wealthy people want to protect the environment, all we have to do today - so we consumers are told - is to go to the supermarket. There are now sustainable and environmentally-friendly products everywhere.
We can therefore seemingly consume more and more without any worries and thereby even do something good for the environment. Almost no product from toilet paper up to cars is sold without the promise that one makes the world a little better.
«Buy me and make this world a little bit better» is the key message found among sustainable brand's marketing. It is argued that the market will fix the climate problem: One does not have to consume less, but only consume in a different way.
Now, however, the validity of this approach is being shaken daily by reports of the consequences of our actions. What we consider sustainable consumption so often leaves behind poverty and environmental destruction elsewhere in the world.
Translated from source: Marcus Jauer. Tages-Anzeiger 10.12.2018 und Sebastian Schoep. Tages-Anzeiger 06.06.2019
© Ulrich Brunner 2024. Wallpaper ©
ra2studio | Shutterstock, Inc. [US] 2018
Anyone who really wants to change something cannot get around thinking about the dogma of «ALWAYS MORE».
No intelligent person still believes that the existing economic system and the level of consumption of the present can be continued for another one or two generations, a thought that would have been self-evident in 1900 or 1950. This makes it clear: we are at the end of something.
Translated from: Blom Philipp. 2020. Das grose Welttheater. Von der Macht der Vorstellungskraft in Zeiten des Umbruchs.
As restrictions on consumption are not even being sought due to the unwanted economic and social consequences, business and politics are focussing on a strategy of promises and consumers on symbolic substitutes.
The order of the day is, for example, fewer cars, fewer cruises and smaller flats. But this will not happen. In the modern capitalist world, which is calibrated for economic growth and consumerism, a politically prescribed shrinking of the economy is simply not enforceable.
Translated from: Beckert Jens. 2024. Verkaufte Zukunft. Warum der Kampf gegen den Klimawandel zu scheitern droht.
The idea that consumption should be limited according to the needs of a planet shared in common by eight billion is, for many, especially in privileged nations, unthinkable as an individual orientation and forgettable as a political program.
Anna Katsman. Planetary Commons. The New Institute. 25.05.2024
It is understandable that the idea of having to renounce some of the wealth you have gained causes anxiety. It helps to realise that a fulfilled life cannot be measured by the number of cruises taken or the size of your wardrobe.
Renunciation is often associated with loss, which leaves a gap forever. But where there are gaps, there is also space for something new.
Translated from: Silvia Liebrich. Wir müssen lernen zu verzichten. Süddeutsche Zeitung. 30. Juli 2022.
We do not have to renounce happiness, well-being and justice, but excessiveness, abundance, stress and consumption decadence.
Translated from: Stefan Brunnhuber. 2023. Die Kunst der Transformation. Wie wir uns anpassen und die Welt verändern.
In rich countries, renunciation means [...] actually nothing more and nothing less than refraining from ruining the planet and in return preserving the basis of life in the future. That's a big word, of course. Couldn't it be a little bit smaller? Unfortunately not.
Translated from: Maja Göpel. 2020. Unsere Welt neu denken. Eine Einladung.
Time is short
© Ulrich Brunner 2024. Wallpaper © JIL Photo and © F-Focus by Mati Kose | Shutterstock, Inc. [US] 2021
Human development has ushered in an era of converging crises: climate change, ecological destruction, disease, pollution, and socioeconomic inequality. […]
Propelled by imperialism, extractive capitalism, and a surging population, we are speeding past Earth's material limits, destroying critical ecosystems, and triggering irreversible changes in biophysical systems that underpin the Holocene*) climatic stability which fostered human civilization.
A critical paradigm shift must occur that replaces exploitative, wealth-oriented capitalism with an economic model that prioritizes sustainability, resilience, and justice.
Charles Fletcher etal. Earth at risk: An urgent call to end the age of destruction and forge a just and sustainable future. PNAS Nexus, Volume 3, Issue 4, April 2024, page106
*) The Holocene is a period in the Earth's history that began around 12,000 years ago and continues to the current day. Global temperature fluctuations during this period averaged only around 1° C.
It is very urgent. System collapse is a real danger. We face tremendous challenges due to rapid population growth, the overuse of resources and associated pollution, the loss of biodiversity, global warming and overall we are experiencing a gradual loss of our basis of existence.
Ernst Ulrich von Weizsäcker and Anders Wijkman - Come on! - Capitalism, Short-Terminism, Population and the Destruction of the Planet. 2017
© Alexandros Michailidis | Shutterstock, Inc. [US] 2024
Our planet has capacity limits for air pollution, biodiversity, the extent of climate change, and other factors. These are boundaries that must be respected if we are to preserve the basis for human life. We have already crossed six out of nine planetary boundaries.
Thomas Krautwig, Anja Krieger. 2022. How we observe planetary boundaries. Helmholtz Climate Initiative.
Licenced under CC BY-NC-ND 3.0 (Credit: Azote for Stockholm Resilience Centre, Stockholm University. Based on Richardson et al. 2023, Steffen et al. 2015, and Rockström et al. 2009
Given the existential threat of climate change, severe weather events, rising sea levels, loss of biodiversity, resource depletion and increasing economic inequality, we are reminded of the importance of developing a sustainable economy that balances economic issues with social and environmental responsibility.
Swiss National Science Foundation. 73 NRP. Sustainable Economy. 2023
© Monkey Business Images | Shutterstock, Inc. [US] 2018
The burdens - from mounting government debts, underfunded pensions, inadequate health and social care to environmental calamity - that we are pushing on to the next generation are unfair, inequitable and irresponsible.
Mark Carney. Value(s) - Building a Better World for All. 2021.
Why does the endless number of widely known problem diagnoses, strategy proposals and calls for action have so little effect in practice and the socio-ecological transformation simply doesn't take place?
Translated from: Ingolfur Blühdorn. Haben wir es gewollt? In: Nachhaltige Nicht-Nachhaltigkeit. 2020. Seiten 31-45
Since the Enlightenment, and massively intensified in the last 50 years, traditional lifestyles with their norms of restriction have been increasingly questioned and replaced by unbounded individual lifestyles.
The liberation from obligations and the comfort that comes with it is experienced as an entitlement and contributes to people ignoring the ecological consequences of their lifestyle. Especially as, in the modern capitalist era, excess is the basic principle of economic activity.
Unlimited individualism sells the future for the next quarterly figures [economics], the upcoming election result [politics] and today's pleasure [civil society].
[...]
The fight against climate change is failing due to the power and incentive structures of a social system geared towards profit generation, consumption and unlimited growth - despite the knowledge of the dangers of future climate change. Time is also running out politically, because climate change is developing dynamically and will therefore become increasingly difficult to manage.
This does not mean that nothing is happening. But it is not enough.
Translated from: Jens Beckert - Director at the Max-Planck Institute for the Study of Societies and Professor of Sociology in Cologne. 2024. Verkaufte Zukunft – Warum der Kampf gegen den Klimawandel zu scheitern droht.
© Ulrich Brunner 2024. Wallpaper © Ranglen | Shutterstock, Inc. [US] 2018
Limiting global temperature rise to 1.5 degrees C above pre-industrial levels is essential for avoiding increasingly severe and widespread climate change impacts.
Doing so requires cutting greenhouse gas emissions 42% by 2030 and 56% by 2035, relative to 2023.
Current policies alone will achieve less than a 1% reduction by 2030 and 2035.
Sophie Boehm etal. 2024. By the Numbers: The Climate Action We Need This Decade. World Resource Institute.
Any further delay in forward-looking global action on adaptation and mitigation will miss a narrow and rapidly closing window of opportunity to secure a liveable and sustainable future for all.
IPCC Intergovernmental Panel On Climate Change. Climate Change 2022 – Impacts, Adaptation and Vulnerability.
Unlike financial crises or pandemics, the damage caused by climate change is irreversible. What we fail to do now cannot be made up for later.
© Tom Toro | CartoonStock 2024